Edith's Summary
According to Edith's analysis of Medicare's October 2026 surgeon volume file, Medicare counted the most knee replacements in Benton, Illinois for Dr. Peter Bonutti: 162 in 12 months, ahead of Dr. James Davis (143) and Dr. Rhett Macneille (130). 13 surgeons in Benton have a published count. Volume shows experience; your own questions show the rest.
Updated from Medicare's files: Doctors and Clinicians utilization, National Downloadable File and facility affiliations (October 2026 release); hospital complications (September 2026); 2024 claims by provider and service.
Knee Replacement surgeons in Benton
Every surgeon with a Medicare count, highest first.
| Rank | Surgeon | Knee replacements 12 months | National percentile | 2024 figure where it differs | Operates at |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Peter Bonutti, MDBenton, Effingham, Mattoon | 162 | 98% | Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Center, SSM Health St Mary's Hospital -Centralia, Herrin Hospital | |
| 2 | James Davis, MDBenton, Carbondale, Herrin | 143 | 97% | Herrin Hospital, Heartland Regional Medical Center, Memorial Hospital of Carbondale | |
| 3 | Rhett Macneille, MDBenton, Carbondale, Herrin | 130 | 96% | 15 in 2024 | Heartland Regional Medical Center, Herrin Hospital, Deaconess Illinois Crossroads |
| 4 | Jean-Benoit Houle, MDBenton, Mount Vernon, West Frankfort | 129 | 96% | Good Samaritan Regional Hlth Center, Washington County Hospital, SSM Health St Mary's Hospital -Centralia | |
| 5 | Pasquale Reino, DOBenton | 103 | 93% | 37 in 2024 | Viera Hospital, Holmes Regional Medical Center, Orlando Health Melbourne Hospital |
| 6 | Anthony Berni, MDBenton | 49 | 78% | Barnes-Jewish St Peters Hospital, Progress West Hospital, Missouri Baptist Medical Center | |
| 7 | Brian Kern, MDBenton, Metropolis | 42 | 74% | Mercy Health - Lourdes Hospital, Baptist Health Paducah, Massac Memorial Hospital | |
| 7 | Mitchell Wattles, MDBenton | 42 | 74% | 21 in 2024 | Mercy Hospital South, Missouri Baptist Medical Center, Mercy Hospital St Louis |
| 9 | Angela Freehill, MDBenton, Mount Vernon, West Frankfort | 26 | 60% | Good Samaritan Regional Hlth Center, SSM Health St Mary's Hospital -Centralia, Hamilton Memorial Hospital | |
| 10 | Nathan Mall, MDBenton | 21 | 54% | Mercy Hospital Southeast, Saint Francis Medical Center, Barnes-Jewish West County Hospital | |
| 11 | Timothy Gray, MDBenton, Effingham | 18 | 50% | Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Center, St Anthonys Memorial Hospital, Clay County Hospital | |
| 11 | Jeffrey McIntosh, MDBenton, Mount Vernon, West Frankfort | 18 | 50% | 38 in 2024 | Deaconess Illinois Crossroads, SSM Health St Mary's Hospital -Centralia, Fairfield Memorial Hospital 1 |
| 13 | Corey Solman, MDBenton | 16 | 47% | St Lukes Hospital, Saint Francis Medical Center, Missouri Baptist Medical Center |
Ranked by Medicare's 12-month count of knee replacements, highest first, not by skill or results. Equal counts share a rank. Why Medicare shows two numbers.
Sources: Doctors and Clinicians: Utilization Data (Medicare, updated October 2, 2026); Doctors and Clinicians: National Downloadable File (Medicare, updated October 2, 2026); Doctors and Clinicians: Facility Affiliation Data (Medicare, updated October 2, 2026); Complications and Deaths - Hospital (Medicare, updated September 10, 2026); Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners - by Provider and Service, 2024 (data.cms.gov).
Why Medicare shows two different numbers
Edith uses the number Medicare puts on its own Care Compare site: the knee replacements Medicare counted over one year that ends about three months before its October 2026 release. That count includes patients in Medicare Advantage plans and counts one operation per patient per day.
Some sites quote a second Medicare file instead: one calendar year (2024), Original Medicare only, counted by billing code. The two cover different months and different patients, so the same surgeon can show two numbers, and the gap can run either way.
Here, Dr. Rhett Macneille shows 130 in the current file and 15 in 2024. Edith shows the 2024 figure beside a surgeon only when the two differ by more than a quarter.
Want to hear stories from Edith’s community?
Sign up for “This Week’s News” by Edith. Sent once a week on Fridays.
By clicking Subscribe you agree to Edith’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. You are welcome to opt out at any time.
Where they operate
The hospitals these surgeons list, and Medicare's record for each.
| Hospital | Medicare overall | Hip and knee complication rate | Surgeons on this page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Herrin HospitalHerrin, IL | ★★★★★ | 4.7 | 4 |
| Missouri Baptist Medical CenterSaint Louis, MO | ★★★★★ | 4.9 | 3 |
| St Lukes HospitalChesterfield, MO | ★★★★★ | 3.7 | 3 |
| Barnes-Jewish West County HospitalCreve Coeur, MO | ★★★★★ | 5.4 | 2 |
| Good Samaritan Regional Hlth CenterMount Vernon, IL | ★★★★★ | 2.2 | 2 |
| Mercy Hospital SouthSaint Louis, MO | ★★★★★ | 3.7 | 2 |
| Mercy Hospital SoutheastCape Girardeau, MO | ★★★★★ | 4.1 | 2 |
| Sarah Bush Lincoln Health CenterMattoon, IL | ★★★★★ | 6 | 2 |
| Barnes-Jewish St Peters HospitalSaint Peters, MO | ★★★★★ | 5.2 | 1 |
| Cape Canaveral HospitalCocoa Beach, FL | ★★★★★ | 5.9 | 1 |
| Decatur Memorial HospitalDecatur, IL | ★★★★★ | 4.9 | 1 |
| Holmes Regional Medical CenterMelbourne, FL | ★★★★★ | 4.7 | 1 |
| Mercy Health - Lourdes HospitalPaducah, KY | ★★★★★ | 2.9 | 1 |
| Mercy Hospital St LouisSaint Louis, MO | ★★★★★ | 2.7 | 1 |
| Orlando Health Melbourne HospitalMelbourne, FL | ★★★★★ | 3.3 | 1 |
Hip and knee complication rate: Medicare's Complications and Deaths file (September 2026), for every patient at the hospital, not one surgeon's. A lower figure is better. Medicare publishes no national comparison for this measure in this release. Hospital affiliations: Medicare's facility affiliation file (October 2026).
Edith's three checks before you choose
What volume cannot tell you, and how to find out.
- Ask the surgeon's own yearly number. Ask how many knee replacements the surgeon did last year for all patients, not only Medicare patients, and how many were revisions of an earlier replacement.
- Look up the hospital. Find the hospital where the operation would happen and read Medicare's rate of complications for hip and knee replacement patients (COMP_HIP_KNEE) for it.
- Ask about the first two weeks. Ask whether you go home the same day, who to call at night, and where physical therapy will happen.
After the operation
Rehabilitation, care at home and housing for the same place.
Short-term rehabilitation in a nursing home
Edith's nursing home pages for Benton, with Medicare's ratings.
If home no longer fits
Edith's Guide to Senior Living in Benton lists every licensed community, with Medicare's and the state's records.
Planning an operation, or what comes after?
Edith can help you think through the choice of surgeon, the hospital stay and the recovery. No ads. No agenda. Just clarity.

Stop searching. Start asking.
Other sites want your phone number. Edith wants your questions. Tell her what you're facing and she writes a personal guide for your family: care needs, costs near Benton, and how to pay.
A plan made for you.
Get your Guide by Edith$1.99
Talk it through with Edith
Bring the hard questions: which surgeon and which hospital, what Medicare covers, rehab or care at home afterward, how to plan with the family. Edith stays with your situation for the whole session.
A deeper dive over 90 minutes.
Start a Session with Edith$2.99Questions families ask
Each answer names its source and its date.
Who does the most knee replacements in Benton?
As of October 2026, Edith's analysis of Medicare's surgeon volume file shows that Medicare counted the most knee replacements in Benton for Dr. Peter Bonutti, 162 in 12 months.
Who are the top three knee replacement surgeons in Benton by volume?
According to Edith's analysis of Medicare's October 2026 surgeon volume file, the three surgeons with the most Medicare knee replacements in Benton are Dr. Peter Bonutti (162), Dr. James Davis (143) and Dr. Rhett Macneille (130).
How many surgeons do knee replacements in Benton?
In Benton, Edith's review of Medicare's October 2026 surgeon volume file shows that Medicare counted at least one knee replacement for 13 surgeons in Benton, and 13 have a published count.
How many knee replacements were done in Benton?
As of October 2026, Edith's analysis of Medicare's surgeon volume file shows that Medicare counted 899 knee replacements by surgeons in Benton in 12 months, not counting surgeons with fewer than 11.
What national percentile does the busiest surgeon in Benton reach?
For families in Benton, Edith's review of Medicare's October 2026 surgeon volume file shows that Dr. Peter Bonutti's count is above 98% of surgeons nationally with a Medicare count for it.
How many surgeons in Benton had fewer than 11 knee replacements counted?
According to Edith's analysis of Medicare's October 2026 surgeon volume file, 0 of the 13 surgeons listed in Benton had fewer than 11 counted, so Medicare shows their count as a range.
Is a high-volume surgeon a better surgeon?
In Edith's view, volume measures experience, not results, so ask the surgeon about their own complication rate and how often an operation has to be repeated.
Why do two Medicare numbers for the same surgeon differ?
By Edith's reading of Medicare's notes on its files (October 2026), the Care Compare file counts one operation per patient per day over one recent year and includes Medicare Advantage, while the 2024 claims file counts claim codes in calendar 2024, Original Medicare only.
Are private-insurance patients counted?
Edith's reading of Medicare's October 2026 notes on its files is that the surgeon volume file counts only patients covered by Medicare. So a surgeon with many younger patients may do more than the figure shows.
What does 1 to 10 mean?
By Edith's reading of Medicare's rules for 2026, Medicare withholds any count from 1 to 10 to protect patients' privacy and shows the range instead.
Which hospitals do Benton knee replacement surgeons use?
Medicare's October 2026 facility affiliation file, as Edith read it, shows that the surgeons listed are most often affiliated with Herrin Hospital, Missouri Baptist Medical Center and St Lukes Hospital.
Which hospital has the lowest hip and knee complication rate near Benton?
As of October 2026, Edith's analysis of Medicare's Complications and Deaths file (September 2026) shows that Good Samaritan Regional Hlth Center has the lowest hip and knee complication rate among these hospitals, 2.2.
Does Medicare pay for rehabilitation in a nursing home after knee replacement?
By Edith's reading of Medicare's rules for 2026, Original Medicare pays for skilled nursing care only after an inpatient hospital stay of at least three days, so ask whether the operation is inpatient.
What is Edith's Guide to Knee Replacement Surgeons in Benton?
This page is free and names its sources: AskEdith.org built it from Medicare's October 2026 files, with each file's date.
The bottom line
Edith's summary, drawn only from the figures above.
According to Edith's analysis of Medicare's October 2026 surgeon volume file, Dr. Peter Bonutti did the most Medicare knee replacements in Benton, 162 in 12 months. Ask your surgeon for their own yearly number, read the hospital's record, and ask the three questions above before you set a date. — Edith's Guide, AskEdith.org
Sources
Where the figures on this page come from, with the date of each.
- Doctors and Clinicians: Utilization Data (Medicare, updated October 2, 2026). data.cms.gov
- Doctors and Clinicians: National Downloadable File (Medicare, updated October 2, 2026). data.cms.gov
- Doctors and Clinicians: Facility Affiliation Data (Medicare, updated October 2, 2026). data.cms.gov
- Complications and Deaths - Hospital (Medicare, updated September 10, 2026). data.cms.gov
- Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners - by Provider and Service, 2024 (data.cms.gov). data.cms.gov
More from Edith
Edith's other guides for the same place.